Belief, Hope, and the Pygmalion Effect on Mental Health

In January 2022 I was sitting on a plane heading back to school after a particularly challenging season at home with family. I was sobbing as I left Logan airport still mourning the loss of my grandfather who had passed away one month earlier. My grandad had had one of the most powerful impacts on me growing up. The reason that flight was so emotional was because I had just realized one of the things I missed about him so much. He believed in me.

There is a psychological concept called the “Pygmalion effect” which claims that believing in someone, having high expectations for a circumstance or person, can bring about better outcomes. It is similar to a self-fulfilling prophesy—it’s an interpersonal self-fulfilling prophesy. If you believe someone can reach their fullest potential, that can be very motivating for that person to continue to work hard at the future you see in them.

Expectations often comes with heavy connotations. Please note the phrase “high expectations” and not “unrealistic expectations.” Just like goldilocks, there certainly can be too low of expectations, too high of expectations, but what Pygmalion effect talking about is “just right” expectations. I would argue that believing in someone’s ability instead of focusing on their inability or disability is an effective way to empower people around you.

Consider this study done by Robert Rosenthal. After running a series of studies in schools with kids at various grade levels he found that “when teachers expected that certain children would show greater intellectual development, those children did show greater intellectual development.” He found that when teachers and parents believed in their student’s capabilities, they were more likely to succeed in school.

What could this look like on a systemic scale? If instead of contributing to popular rhetoric like “I’m scared for this generation,” or “this generation is so addicted to their phones,” we begin to see what the younger generations can bring instead will help them live up to their fullest potentials.

How can I believe in my child if I do not have hope myself? Maybe you are in a situation where hope seems impossible. On an airplane we’re told to put our own oxygen mask on ourselves first before helping others. In the same way, maybe this has to be your starting place before you can help others around you get healthy. If that is the case for you, find people who can believe it for you and with you. Put yourself in environments and communities where you can benefit from the Pygmalion effect yourself. Like my grandfather did for me. Commit to your recovery. Figure out what self-care means to you. Believe in the process, even when it’s hard. At Revidas, our clinicians use evidence-based practices to help our clients in the darkest of circumstances. Believing in yourself to help empower your children could be one of the most important things you ever do.

Today, a large part of why I want to be a social worker is to honor my grandfather’s legacy who spent his whole career as a pastor believing in his community. What does believe that today can be better than yesterday look like for you, your family and your community?

References:

Rosenthal R & Jacobson L. Pygmalion in the classroom: teacher expectation and pupils’ intellectual development. New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston, 1968. 240 p. [Harvard Univ., Boston, MA and South San Francisco Unified Sch. District, San Francisco, CA]

Let’s Take the Next Step Together

Better days are just around the corner with therapy from our team at Revidas.